A Critical Ethnographic Study of Families of Brain Dead Patients: Their Experiences and Attitudes to Organ Donation

Hedayat Allah Lalegani, Sima Babaei, Nasrollah Alimohammadi, Ahmadreza Yazdannik, Behnam Sanei, Pantea Ramezannezhad6

Abstract


Background: Despite the difficulty of making decisions providing facilitating mediators and removing barriers to making decisions about choosing the right path to donate the organs of brain‑dead patients by families can assist in improving the services and help the lives of fellow human beings. This study aimed to explain the decision‑making mediator for organ donation in families with brain‑dead patients in a cultural context.

Materials and Methods: This qualitative study with a critical ethnographic approach was conducted based on Carspecken’s stages from August 2021 to March 2022. In this regard, 22 participants were selected through the purposive sampling method and considering the inclusion and exclusion criteria. Sampling was continued until data saturation. After obtaining the required ethical approval, data collection was performed through observation, semi‑structured interviews, and document review. All data were recorded and managed using MAXQDA 18 software.

Results: Based on the results, the main themes and subthemes of this study included “inefficient decision‑making mediator” (the shadow of the socioeconomic situation on the medical status of organ recipients, as well as pessimistic influential individuals, social accountability, dialect difference, and ethnic beliefs) and “efficient decision‑making mediator” (social learning, material, and spiritual motivation, mother role, and divine reward).

Conclusions: The results of this study, derived from a cultural context, can be applied to carrying out future applied and empirical research. Moreover, they can be used in the field of various nursing roles, especially management, care, and education.



Keywords


Anthropology, brain death, cultural, decision‑making, organ transplantation

Full Text:

PDF

References


Spears W, Mian A, & Greer D. 2022. Brain death: a clinical overview. Journal of Intensive Care, 10;1-16.

Bhosale AV, Vibhute BB, Zirpe DK, Sable S. Liver retrieval from brain dead kidney transplant recipient–Expanding the organ pool case report. Indian J Transplant 2020;14:266.

Lomero M, Gardiner D, Coll E, Haase-Kromwijk B, Procaccio F, Immer F, et al. Donation after circulatory death today: An updated overview of the European landscape. Transpl Int 2020;33:76 88.

Srivastava A, Mani A. Deceased organ donation and transplantation in India: Promises and challenges. Neurol India 2018;66:316 22.

Abbasi P, Yoosefi Lebni J, Nouri P, Ziapour A, Jalali A. The obstacles to organ donation following brain death in Iran: A qualitative study. BMC Med Ethics 2020;21:1 9. doi: 10.1186/ s12910 020 00529 8.

Mohammadpour M, Mohammadpour A, Ajam Zibad H, Najafi S. A study on the awareness, attitudes and performance of teachers towards the organ donation during 2016 2017. Nurs Pract Today 2018;5:299 309.

Degheili JA, Yacoubian A, Dargham RA, Rkein G, Khauli R. Cadaveric organ donation in Lebanon: Proposed suggestions for improvement. Transplant Proc 2020;52:37 41.

Iranian society of Organ donation. Statistics. 2021. Available from: https://ehdacenter.ir/archive/article/2759553/%D8%A2%D9%85% D8%A7%D8%B18/14/20. [Last accessed on 2023 Aug 18].

Etheredge H, Penn C, Watermeyer J. Opt-in or opt-out to increase organ donation in South Africa? Appraising proposed strategies using an empirical ethics analysis. Dev World Bioeth 2018;18:119 25.

Sque M, Walker W, Long Sutehall T, Morgan M, Randhawa G, Rodney A. Bereaved donor families’ experiences of organ and tissue donation, and perceived influences on their decision making. J Crit Care 2018;45:82 9.

Parsa P, Taheri M, Rezapur Shahkolai F, Shirahmadi S. Attitudes of Iranian students about organ donation: A qualitative study. BMC Med Ethics 2019;20:1 11.

Anthony SJ, Lin J, Pol SJ, Wright L, Dhanani S. Family veto in organ donation: The experiences of organ and tissue donation coordinators in Ontario. Can J Anesth 2021;68:611 21.

Hosinrezaei H, Ranjbar H, Arab M. Brain death and organ donation: Experiences of families. J Qual Res Health Sci 2020;1:34 40.

Siminoff LA, Bolt S, Gardiner HM, Alolod GP. Family first: Asian Americans’ attitudes and behaviors toward deceased organ donation. J Racial Ethn Health Disparities 2020;7:72 83.

Li MT, Hillyer GC, Husain SA, Mohan S. Cultural barriers to organ donation among Chinese and Korean individuals in the United States: A systematic review. Transpl Int 2019;32:1001 18.

Shaw D. Presumed evidence in deemed consent to organ donation. J Intensive Care Soc 2018;19:2 3.

Krupic F. The Impact of Religion and Provision of Information on Increasing Knowledge and Changing Attitudes to Organ Donation: An Intervention Study. Journal of religion and health. 2020;59:2082-95.

Cruz EV, Higginbottom G. The use of focused ethnography in nursing research. Nurse Res. 2013;20:36-43.

LoBiondo Wood G, Haber J. Nursing Research E Book: Methods and Critical Appraisal for Evidence Based Practice. India, Elsevier Health Sciences; 2021. Available form: https:// books.google.com/books?hl=fa&lr=&id=l8M1EAAAQBAJ&oi=f nd&pg=PP1&dq=biblography%2B+LoBiondo%E2%80%91Woo d+G,+Haber+J.+Nursing+Research+E%E2%80%91Book:+Meth ods+and+Critical+Appraisal+for+Evidence%E2%80%91Based+ Practice.+Elsevier+Health+Sciences%3B+2021.&ots=NHxvw7o1 Cj&sig=8t1rNuxeaudyPY_r5lBp2ZFxTsA#v=onepage&q&f=fals e. [Last accessed on 2021 Jun 29].

Bidabadi FS, Yazdannik A, Zargham Boroujeni A. Patient’s dignity in intensive care unit: A critical ethnography. Nurs Ethics 2019;26:738 52.

Starfield S. Autoethnography and critical ethnography. In The Routledge Handbook of Research Methods in Applied Linguistics. Routledge; 2019. p. 165 75.

Luciani M, Campbell K, Tschirhart H, Ausili D, Jack SM. How to design a qualitative health research study. Part 1: Design and purposeful sampling considerations. Prof Inferm 2019;72:152 61.

Martin Ferreres ML, Pardo MÁDJ, Porras DB, Moya JLM. An ethnographic study of human dignity in nursing practice. Nurs Outlook 2019;67:393 403.

Lowe RJ. Frame analysis in critical ethnography: Applications for ELT research.Language, Culture and Curriculum 2020;34:307 20.

Paradis-Gagné E, Pariseau-Legault P. Critical ethnography of outreach nurses–perceptions of the clinical issues associated with social disaffiliation and stigma. J Adv Nur 2021;77:1357 67.

Newnham E, Small K, Allen J. Critical ethnography in maternity care research: Bridging creativity and rigour–a discussion paper. Midwifery 2021;99:103014. doi: 10.1016/j.midw.2021.103014.

Campbell KA, Orr E, Durepos P, Nguyen L, Li L, Whitmore C, et al. Reflexive thematic analysis for applied qualitative health research. Qual Rep 2021;26:2011 28.

Beigzadeh A, Bahmanbijari B, Salajegheh M, Haghdoost AA, Rezaei H. Factors influencing decisions on organ donation in brain death patients. J Emerg Pract Trauma 2015;1:60 6.

Arslantas R, Çevik BE. Factors affecting organ donation rate during devastating brain injuries: A 6 year data analysis. Acta Chir Belg 2021;121:242 47.

de Groot J, van Hoek M, Hoedemaekers C, Hoitsma A, Schilderman H, Smeets W, et al. Request for organ donation without donor registration: A qualitative study of the perspectives of bereaved relatives. BMC Med Ethics 2016;17:1 14. doi: 10.1186/s12910 016 0120 6.

Ahmadian S, Rahimi A, Khaleghi E. Outcomes of organ donation in brain dead patient’s families: Ethical perspective. Nurs Ethics 2019;26:256 69.

Kentish Barnes N, Cohen Solal Z, Souppart V, Cheisson G, Joseph L, Martin Lefèvre L, et al. Being convinced and taking responsibility: A qualitative study of family members’ experience of organ donation decision and bereavement after brain death. Critical care medicine 2019;47:526 34.

Miller C, Breakwell R. What factors influence a family’s decision to agree to organ donation? A critical literature review. London J Prim Care 2018;10:103 7.

Shacham E, Loux T, Barnidge EK, Lew D, Pappaterra L. Determinants of organ donation registration. Am J Transplant 2018;18:2798 803.

Shemie SD, Robertson A, Beitel J, Chandler J, Ferre E, Evans J, et al. End of life conversations with families of potential donors: Leading practices in offering the opportunity for organ donation. Transplantation 2017;101:S17 26.

Fernandes MEN, Bittencourt ZZLDC, Boin IDFSF. Experiencing organ donation: Feelings of relatives after consent1. Rev Lat Am Enfermagem 2015;23:895 901.

Kananeh MF, Brady PD, Mehta CB, Louchart LP, Rehman MF, Schultz LR, et al. Factors that affect consent rate for organ donation after brain death: A 12 year registry. J Neurol Sci 2020;416:117036. doi: 10.1016/j.jns.2020.117036.

Kerstis B, Widarsson M. When life ceases—Relatives’ experiences when a family member is confirmed brain dead and becomes a potential organ donor—A literature review. SAGE Open Nurs 2020;6:2377960820922031. doi: 10.1177/2377960820922031.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.