Critique of the Peaceful End of Life Theory Using Meleis’ 2012 Approach
Abstract
Background: Providing a peaceful end of life while preserving dignity is a fundamental goal of nursing care. The Peaceful End‑of‑Life Theory (PELT) offers a middle‑range theoretical framework to guide holistic nursing care for terminally ill patients. Despite its broad application, this theory has not yet been systematically critiqued using Meleis’ theory analysis framework.
Materials and Methods: This study presents a theoretical discussion employing a structured critique based on Afaf Meleis’ (2012) theory analysis framework. The structural and functional components of PELT—including its concepts, assumptions, propositions, inner dimensions, clarity, consistency, practical, educational, and research utility, as well as empirical support—were systematically examined. The primary source of analysis was the original theory article by Ruland and Moore (1998), supported by relevant theoretical and empirical literature.
Results: The analysis identified PELT as a coherent and internally consistent middle‑range theory that effectively links nursing interventions to holistic patient outcomes such as pain relief, comfort, dignity, peace, and closeness to significant others. However, several limitations were noted, including insufficient operational guidance for prioritizing interventions, challenges in measuring culturally sensitive concepts such as peace and comfort, and systemic barriers to implementation such as nursing shortages and misalignment with diagnosis‑focused reimbursement systems.
Conclusions: Although PELT provides a valuable conceptual framework for guiding end‑of‑life nursing care, its effective application requires further development of context‑specific clinical guidelines, culturally sensitive and validated assessment tools, and supportive health policies that acknowledge the interdisciplinary and resource‑intensive nature of palliative care. Addressing these gaps may enhance the theory’s practical applicability and contribute to more equitable and dignified end‑of‑life care across diverse settings.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Ngabonziza S, Murekatete MC, Nyiringango G, Musabwasoni SMG. Peaceful end of life theory: A critical analysis of its use to improve nursing practice. Rwanda J Med Health Sci 2021;4:412 7.
Nacak UA, Erden Y. End of life care and nurse’s roles. Eurasian J Med 2022;54(Suppl 1):141 4.
Ruland CM, Moore SM. Theory construction based on standards of care: A proposed theory of the peaceful end of life. Nurs Outlook 1998;46:169 75.
Zaccara AAL, Costa SFGd, Nóbrega MMLd, França JRFdS, Morais GSdN, Fernandes MA. A analysis and assessment of the peaceful end of life theory according to Fawcett’s criteria1. Texto Contexto Enferm 2018;26:e2920017.
Montano AR. Neuman systems model with nurse led interprofessional collaborative practice. Nurs Sci Q 2021;34:45 53.
Santos M, Bittencourt G, Beserra P, Nóbrega M. Orem’s general self care theory according to Meleis’ model for theory analysis. Rev Enf Ref 2022;6:e21047.
Meleis, A. (2012) Theoretical Nursing Development and Progress. 5th edi. Philadelphia: Lippincott William and Wilkins, Wolters Kluwer.
Alligood MR. Nursing Theorists and Their Work. In: Alexopoulos Y, editor. Elsevier Mosby. 10th edition. MOSBY Elsevier. USA; 2017.
Adi Wijaya Y, Yudhawati N, Ilmy S. Theory of practice: A peaceful end of life (EoL) related to the development of nursing interventions in supportive therapy area. Nurs Sci 2022;3:1.
LoPorto J. Application of the Donabedian quality of care model to New York State direct support professional core competencies: How structure, process, and outcomes impacts disability services. J Sustain Soc Change 2020;12:5.
Guta NM. Application of Donabedian quality of care framework to assess quality of neonatal resuscitation, its outcome, and associated factors among resuscitated newborns at public hospitals of East Wollega zone, Oromia, Western Ethiopia, 2021. BMC Pediatr 2022;22:605.
Shroyer AL, Carr BM, Grover FL. Health services information: Application of Donabedian’s framework to improve the quality of clinical care. Health Services Evaluation. Springer, New York, NY; 2019. p. 109 39.
Tossaint Schoenmakers R, Versluis A, Chavannes N, Talboom Kamp E, Kasteleyn M. The challenge of integrating eHealth into health care: Systematic literature review of the Donabedian model of structure, process, and outcome. J Med Internet Res 2021;23:e27180.
Kongsuwan W, Locsin RC. Promoting peaceful death in the intensive care unit in Thailand. Int Nurs Rev 2009;56:116 22.
Jimenez O JB, Trajera SM, Ching GS. Providing end of life care to COVID 19 patients: The lived experiences of ICU nurses in the Philippines. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2022;19:12953.
Kim C G, Lee YH. Nurses’ experiences of end of life care of older adults with dementia. Korean J Adult Nurs 2017;29:119 30.
Saldana Agudelo G, Guiza Romero A, Vesga Gualdrón L. Peaceful end of life in an unviable newborn: A case report. Indian J Palliative Care 2020;26:388.
Back AL, Fromme EK, Meier DE. Training clinicians with communication skills needed to match medical treatments to patient values. J Am Geriatr Soc 2019;67:S435 41.
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. End of life Care for Adults: Service Delivery. London: NICE; 2019. (NICE guideline NG142). Available from: https://www.nice.org.uk/ guidance/ng142. [Last accessed on 2024 Jan 02].
McEwan M, Wills EM. Theoretical Basis for Nursing: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins; 2021.
Grant M, de Graaf E, Teunissen S. A systematic review of classifications systems to determine complexity of patient care needs in palliative care. Palliat Med 2021;35:636 50.
Gupta M, Pruthi G, Gupta P, Singh K, Kanwat J, Tiwari A. Impact of End of life nursing education consortium on palliative care knowledge and attitudes towards care of dying of nurses in India: A quasi experimental pre post study. Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2023;40:529 38.
Glover TL, Ehrlich O, Davis A, Lippe M, Cormack CL, Jizba T, et al. An end of life nursing education consortium (ELNEC) regional approach to integrating primary palliative care in nursing education. J Prof Nurs 2025;58:77 82.
Specialty Palliative Care Certification. Available from: https:// www.capc.org/jobs/palliative-care-certification/. [Last accessed on 2023 Dec 10].
Guthrie DM, Williams N, Beach C, Buzath E, Cohen J, Declercq A, et al. A multi stage process to develop quality indicators for community based palliative care using interRAI data. Plos One 2022;17:e0266569.
Takaoka Y, Hamatani Y, Shibata T, Oishi S, Utsunomiya A, Kawai F, et al. Quality indicators of palliative care for cardiovascular intensive care. J Intensive Care 2022;10:15.
Temkin Greener H, Li Q, Li Y, Segelman M, Mukamel DB. End of life care in nursing homes: from care processes to quality. J Palliat Med 2016;19:1304 11.
Ruland CM, White T, Stevens M, Fanciullo G, Khilani SM. Effects of a computerized system to support shared decision making in symptom management of cancer patients: Preliminary results. J Am Med Inform Assoc 2003;10:573 9.
Albert RH. End of life care: managing common symptoms. Am Fam Physician 2017;95:356 61.
Palliative care. 2020. Available from: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/palliative-care. [Last accessed on 2020 Aug 05].
End of life and palliative care explained. Available from: https:// www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/servicesandsupport/end-oflife-and-palliative-care-explained. [Last accessed on 2023 Dec 10].
Available from: https://www.racgp.org.au/clinical-resources/ clinical-guidelines/key-racgp-guidelines/view-all-racgp-guidelines/silver-book/part-a/palliative-care.
Available from: https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/end-of-life-care/. [Last accessed on 2023 Dec 12].
Kennedy G. The importance of patient dignity in care at the end of life. The. Ulster Med J 2016;85:45 8.
Östlund U, Blomberg K, Söderman A, Werkander Harstäde C. How to conserve dignity in palliative care: Suggestions from older patients, significant others, and healthcare professionals in Swedish municipal care. BMC Palliat Care 2019;18:10.
Wilkie DJ, Johnson B, Mack AK, Labotka R, Molokie RE. Sickle cell disease: An opportunity for palliative care across the life span. Nurs Clin North Am 2010;45:375 97.
Alyami K, Bristowe K, Dzeng E, Afolabi O, Evans CJ. Palliative care needs of adults severely affected by sickle cell disease: A mixed methods systematic review. Int J Nurs Stud 2026;174:105278.
Nwogu Onyemkpa E, Collins G, Erondu M, Kaye EC. Involving palliative care to improve outcomes in sickle cell disease. N Engl J Med 2025;393:1553 6.
Kehl KA, Kirchhoff KT, Kramer BJ, Hovland Scafe C. Challenges facing families at the end of life in three settings. J Soc Work End Life Palliat Care 2009;5:144 68.
Abrahamson V, Wilson P, Barclay S, Brigden C, Gage H, Greene K, et al. Family carer experiences of hospice care at home: Qualitative findings from a mixed methods realist evaluation. Palliat Med 2023;37:1529 39.
Xu Y, Liu Y, Kang Y, Wang D, Zhou Y, Wu L, et al. Experiences of family caregivers of patients with end of life cancer during the transition from hospital to home palliative care: A qualitative study. BMC Palliat Care 2024;23:230.
Munkombwe WM, Petersson K, Elgán C. Nurses’ experiences of providing nonpharmacological pain management in palliative care: A qualitative study. J Clin Nurs 2020;29:1643 52.
Available from: https://comfortandpeacehospice.com/. [Last accessed on 2023 Dec 15].
Available from: https://suncoasthospice.org/hospice-nurse-crisis-care-support-comfort-and-peace/. [Last accessed on 2023 Dec 15].
Available from: https://pinesofpeace.org/.[Last accessed on 2023 Dec 10].
Available from: https://www.ohioshospice.org/peace-comfort-dignity-heart-hospice/. [Last accessed on 2023 Dec 15].
Available from: https://www.nhpco.org/hospice-care-overview/. [Last accessed on 2023 Dec 12].
Available from: https://www.helpguide.org/articles/caregiving/ hospice-and-palliative-care.htm. [Last accessed on 2023 Dec 10].
Rahemi Z, Malatyali A, Wiese LAK, Dye CJ. End of life care planning in diverse individuals across age groups: A proposed conceptual model of nursing. J Nurs Care Qual 2023;38:319 26.
de Azevedo Ponte KM, da Silva LdF, de Araújo Aragão AE, Vilani M, Guedes C, Zagonel IPS. Clinical nursing care to comfort women with acute myocardial infarction. Texto Contexto Enferm 2014;23:56 64.
Hansson H, Björk M, Santacroce SJ, Raunkiær M. End‐of‐life palliative home care for children with cancer: A qualitative study on parents’ experiences. Scand J Caring Sci 2023;37:917 26.
Dellon EP, Goggin J. End of life care in cystic fibrosis in the era of new therapies. Lancet Respir Med 2023;11:861 3.
Walling AM, Brown Saltzman K, Barry T, Quan RJ, Wenger NS. Assessment of implementation of an order protocol for end of life symptom management. J Palliat Med 2008;11:857 65.
Li X, Kongsuwan W, Yodchai K. Attitude toward care of the dying and practice of peaceful end of life care in community hospitals in China. Int Nurs Rev 2023;70:345 54.
Connor SR, Gwyther E. The Worldwide Hospice Palliative Care Alliance. J Pain Symptom Manage 2018;55:S112-6. [doi: 10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2017.03.020].
International association for Hospice and palliative care. Available from: https://hospicecare.com/what-we-do/programs/ traveling-scholars/. [Last accessed on 2023 Dec 10].
Austin P, MacLeod R. Finding peace in clinical settings: A narrative review of concept and practice. Palliat Support Care 2017;15:490 8.
Tan SB, Ng CG, Subramaniam P, Lim EJ, Loh EC. Inner peace in palliative care patients: A qualitative study using grounded theory. BMJ Support Palliat Care 2012;2(Suppl 1):A37 A.
Planning End of Life Care. 2022. Available from: https://starship. org.nz/guidelines/planning-end-of-life-care/. [Last accessed on 2023 Dec 15].
Vogl M, Schildmann E, Leidl R, Hodiamont F, Kalies H, Maier BO, et al. Redefining diagnosis related groups (DRGs) for palliative care A cross sectional study in two German centres. BMC Palliat Care 2018;17:58.
Abu Odah H, Molassiotis A, Liu J. Challenges on the provision of palliative care for patients with cancer in low and middle income countries: A systematic review of reviews. BMC Palliat Care 2020;19:55.
Becker C, Leidl R, Schildmann E, Hodiamont F, Bausewein C. A pilot study on patient related costs and factors associated with the cost of specialist palliative care in the hospital: First steps towards a patient classification system in Germany. Cost Eff Resour Alloc 2018;16:35.
Barbero E, Beas E, Ela S, González Barboteo J, Gómez Batiste X, Limonero JT, et al. Development of a tool to identify and assess psychosocial and spiritual needs in end of life patients: The ENP E scale. Palliat Support Care 2018;17:441 7.
Feliciano DR, Reis Pina P. Enhancing end of life care with home based palliative interventions: A systematic review. J Pain Symptom Manage 2024;68:e356 72.
Al Shammari MA, Yasir A, Aldoori N, Mohammad H. Using normalization process theory to evaluate an end of life pediatric palliative care web based training program for nurses: Protocol for a randomized controlled trial. JMIR Res Protoc 2022;11:e23783.
Syan SAE, Ali HM, Ahmed AHAA. The effect of web based pediatric palliative care educational sessions on knowledge and reported practices of nurses at Assiut University Children’s Hospital. Tanta Sci Nurs J 2023;31:212 30.
Jouybari L, Sanagou A, Haghparast A. Application of kolcaba comfort theory in the postpartum period to promote the effective breastfeeding: A case study. J Nurs Educ 2023;12:62 74.
Lin Y, Zhou Y, Chen C. Interventions and practices using comfort theory of Kolcaba to promote adults’ comfort: An evidence and gap map protocol of international effectiveness studies. Syst Rev 2023;12:33.
Sulistyawati E, Aprilia Z, Bangun M, editors. Application of Katherine Kolcaba’s Comfort Theory in Overcoming Fatigue in Children with Cancer Undergoing Chemotherapy. 1st Lawang Sewu International Symposium 2022 on Health Sciences (LSISHS 2022), Atlantis Press, 2023.
Sepahvand F, Valizadeh F, Khanjarian F. Application of Kolcaba’s theory of comfort for a 12 year old epileptic adolescent admitted to the emergency room: A case study. Interdiscip J Acute Care 2021;2:31 41.
Lin Y, Zhou Y, Chen C, Yan C, Gu J. Application of Kolcaba’s Comfort Theory in healthcare promoting adults’ comfort: A scoping review. BMJ Open 2024;14:e077810.
Kahraman Berberoğlu B, Çalişir H. The effect of structured supportive approach based on Kolcaba’s comfort theory applied to parents of children with cerebral palsy on child’s comfort, quality of life, and parent’s self efficacy: A randomised controlled trial. J Pediatr Nurs 2024;75:e65 74.
Khaleghi M, Fomani FK, Hoseini ASS. The effect of the comfort care model on distress, pain, and hemodynamic parameters in infants after congenital heart defect surgery. J Neonatal Nurs 2023;29:108 16.
The first international congress of palliative care and support for the elderly. 2023. Available from: https://www.en.symposia.ir/ PSCE01. [Last accessed on 2023 Mar 05].
Fereidouni A, Salesi M, Rassouli M, Hosseinzadegan F, Javid M, Karami M, et al. Preferred place of death and end of life care for adult cancer patients in Iran: A cross sectional study. Front Oncol 2022;12:911397.
Available from: https://www.crossroadshospice.com/ media/1263/5064_culturalinfluence_wp.pdf. [Last accessed on 2025 Mar 31].
Glyn Blanco MB, Lucchetti G, Badanta B. How do cultural factors influence the provision of end of life care? A narrative review. Appl Nurs Res 2023;73:151720.
Hira V, Palnati SR, Bhakta S. Understanding the influence of culture on end of life, palliative, and hospice care: A narrative review. Cureus 2025;17:e87960.
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.